To begin with, no, I don’t think it will be good (and by good, I mean worthy of the franchise, which is technically far more than good) and no I don’t think David Yates is a good choice for director.
Now I’ve got that summary out of that way, let me talk about why of it all.
Why I don’t think the movie will be particularly good:
To begin with Doctor Who doesn’t exactly have a good history on the big screen, I’m talking of course about the famously terrible ‘96 movie, which I admittedly have not seen, but have read/heard about and as such, don’t particularly want to see. That movie seems to have been received so poorly primarily because it Americanized something that is so inherently British. Taking away the British-isms, the skilled almost entirely British actors and writers and the whole un-blockbuster-y feel that the show has is never going to be a good idea. I am aware that Yates is British, but there’s is consideration for both American writers and an American Doctor at this point so the point still stands.
Also, I’m not trying to be racist, but it’s unavoidable.. British is stuff is just better. And, as I am neither from the UK or the US I am about as neutral as a Doctor Who fan can be.
Futhermore, I understand that this is a fairly weak reason to not look forward to the movie, but it’s an unavoidable one, so I had to say it.
Reason the second, is that the movie is very obviously intended to be big, a blockbuster and a money spinner. The choice of Yates as a director indicates that pretty clearly (more on him in a moment) if nothing else. I understand perfectly well that Doctor Who is a BIG THING, with a huge fanbase, but at least outside of the UK it is a cult fan-base. Of course this is growing (the fact that I’m even writing this is proof of that much) and of course it should grow, because the show deserves to be all that it can be. But a big ol’ movie is sure as hell not the way to do it. What, might I ask, is wrong with the way the DW fanbase is expanding all over the world through word of mouth, through each person passing on the brilliance of the show to everyone they know, in an incredibly exciting cycle that results in dedicated, hard-core fans? I think that’s brilliant, especially compared to expanding a fan-base by a big budget film that has the potential to draw millions of shoddy, fair weather fans.
Annnnd finally, let us discuss the decision to make the movie as a stand-alone, apart from the show and with a completely new Doctor. First of all, I do think this is a good idea, because at least if it’s crap it’s not going to impact too much on the show itself. But, mostly, I’m a little angered by the implausibly of it.. I mean, where is this regeneration going to fit in? As an in-between Doctor between 10 and 11 or 11 and 12? Come on guys, IT MAKES NO SENSE! The Doctor is not the sort of character you can freely adapt, he is one very very important man, and his time-line is the basis of the show. If they mess around with this, what else will they change?
Why I don’t think David Yates is good choice of director:
I have a whole lot of things I could write here, but I can summarise them adequately in one sentence-
I love Harry Potter with an intense passion and have done for at least half my life, but I find the movies … passable.
Let me conclude my rant by saying, I do think it’s okay for shows to change, especially since the ability to adapt and grow is why DW will celebrate it’s 50th anniversary is 2013, but I do not hold high hopes for this movie for the reasons I have outlined above, and several more. All the same; when Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part two hit cinemas, I put on make-up, a cloak and a bald cap and cosplayed Voldemort and when this movie comes out, I intend to walk the streets of Melbourne as a Weeping Angel. Because that’s what a Whovian does.
If you actually read all of this, thank-you! Drop me a message in my ask with your own opinions and I’ll be sure to give you a follow :)
Little J out x